Unit 3: Political Parties, Interest Groups, and Mass Media
“Seven States Challenge Birth Control Coverage Rule”
http://constitutioncenter.org/NewsWire.aspx?title=Seven+States+Challenge+Birth+Control+Coverage+Rule
Synopsis: The first legal challenge of the Obama administration mandate on birth control coverage has occurred. The mandate requires that all employers give their employees birth control coverage, including those of religious-affiliated hospitals, schools, and outreach programs. Seven states, Nebraska, Florida, Michigan, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, and Texas, have filed a lawsuit claiming that the mandate violates the First Amendment right to freedom of religion. Also, the lawsuit claims that the mandate might force religious employers and organizations to drop health insurance coverage, leading more people to enroll in Medicaid programs and increase patient numbers at state-subsidized hospitals and medical centers. The Obama administration has said that they do not want to “abridge anyone’s religious freedom but they want to give women access to preventive care.” The administration has also said that they will shift the requirement from the employers to health insurers.
Analysis: I think that the Obama administration is in a predicament. In trying to appeal to women and liberals, they have angered many conservatives and the Catholic Church. However, both sides do have reasoning and constitutional supports. Women want their right to choice and the Catholic Church wants their right to freedom of religion and to not be pressured into supporting something that they don’t believe in. I think that the administration’s idea of shifting the mandate to the health insurers would be a good compromise because then no one’s right to freedom of religion would be violated nor would be any woman’s right to choice be violated.